TOL: Vegan Cheese Taste Test

TOL: Vegan Cheese Taste Test

Cheese…so many people ask me how I can live without cheese/dairy. Why can’t I just “take a small amount” of cheese? What would happen if I ate a tiny bit of it? Well, I’ve come to the conclusion that dairy is no good for my body. It’s terrible for my skin, it makes me feel bloated, crampy, and terrible all around. I can honestly say that I don’t really miss cheese too much but over the years, I have found some great non-dairy cheese alternatives that I sometimes enjoy.

Before beginning, I’d like to say that for the most part, I just avoid cheese and cheese substitutes all together. I think that many of the cheese substitutes are not really the healthiest options out there and I’d rather sub avocado or something a bit healthier if I can. That being said, sometimes a gal just needs wants some “cheese”! Today I’ll be sharing 4 non-dairy cheese options with you for those moments when you JUST NEED SOME CHEESE RIGHT NOW…and don’t want to have dairy!

Cheese #1: Treeline Treenut Cheese Herb & Garlic

Garlic & Herb spread

  • Taste: AMAZING! This cheese is soft and spreadable and would be perfect for a party on a cheese and crackers tray.
  • Ingredients: Really simple! There were zero questionable ingredients!
  • Texture: Perfect! It’s really easy to dip and/or spread and the cheese keeps in the fridge for 2 weeks! Although, I doubt it will last that long in my fridge!
  • Overall: 10/10 I was super impressed with this cheese & had I not known, I would have thought it was a fancy brie cheese!

Cheese #2: The Original Almond Cheddar Style Block

Cheddar Style Block

  • Taste: Very similar taste to Velveeta style cheese which I grew up eating. There was a slightly bitter aftertaste.
  • Ingredients: Ingredient list far too long for everyday eating but nothing too scary added.
  • Texture: A bit too mushy and soft, good for slicing for grilled cheese though!
  • Overall: 6.5/10 I was not super impressed overall with this cheese. I think it will make for some yummy grilled cheese sandwiches, but not sure I’d buy it to eat plain with crackers. 

Cheese #3: The Original Almond Cheddar Shreds

Cheddar Style Almond

  • Taste: Same flavor as the block cheese. When melted, the taste was pretty bland.
  • Ingredients: Same as the block, a lot of ingredients and I would not want to be eating it every day. Good for a  cheese splurge though!
  • Texture: Texture when you touch it is almost stretchy. I made a mini quesadilla on a corn tortilla and it melted very well. 
  • Overall: 7/10 I enjoyed the shreds better than the block and would consider using this on a pasta dish or tacos. 

Cheese #4: Chao Slices Tomato Cayenne with Spicy Peppers

Chao Slices

  • Taste: Very delicious! The spicy flavors from the pepper along with the tomato cayenne made for a really tasty combo! 
  • Ingredients: Pretty good! Nothing questionable like the almond cheeses! 
  • Texture: Slightly harder than traditional cheese slices, very slightly rubbery consistency. This cheese does not seem to melt very well but is great on crackers!
  • Overall: 9/10 Minus the lack of melting, the taste really is good on this kind! 

In the end, I’d highly recommend cheese #1 & cheese #4! I hope you found this intriguing, interesting, and/or helpful! I’d love to hear of any non-dairy cheeses you enjoy so I can give them a try! I’ve also tried a lot of the Go Veggie products and Daiya products with some luck. Big thanks to Amanda for letting me think out loud today! 

Favorite Vegan Cheese? Would you ever eat non-dairy cheese? What’s one food you think you could not live without? 

Tell me in the comments below!

You May Also Enjoy:

Recent GF/Dairy-Free Finds

I got 99 problems…& they’re all digestion

Favorite Gluten Free Swaps


Like & Share!

21 thoughts on “TOL: Vegan Cheese Taste Test

  1. I’m so glad there are cheese replacements because life is better with cheese 😀
    I haven’t tried a ton of vegan cheeses, but I like the shredded Daiya cheese pretty good.

  2. This was really helpful! I tried my first vegan cheese the other day (it was from Trader Joes) and it was alright. I had it on a homemade pizza and it melted perfectly, but it tasted a little off to me! Dan loved it though, so maybe it’s just me 🙂

  3. We actually used a Vegan cheese replacement for a friend who couldn’t have dairy a couple months ago, and I”m not sure I could tell the difference. I thought it was amazing how it melted. This was a really neat review. I’m going to have to keep an eye out for more vegan cheese.

    • This Chao stuff is so good! They have 3 or 4 different flavors of them. I know theyre sold in Canada because I watched someone cooking a recipe with it from Canada. Unfortunately, they didnt say where they got it though!

  4. I’ve never tried non-dairy cheese, but this is interesting to me. I feel the same way you described when I eat dairy, so I mostly avoid it. I’m not a big cheese eater anyways. I don’t really like the texture. I can handle melted cheese easier, but in small amounts. And, I absolutely hate velveeta! I think it’s because I grew up eating it on everything. My mom loved it. Now I can’t stand the taste of it and my husband always wants me to make cheese dip with it. I’m glad you shared this. I’ll have to check our local health food store to see if they have any of these!

    • Yeah, I grew up with a lot of Velveeta too! I got all of this cheese at our local organic market which is basically a small version of a Whole Foods.

  5. I actually didn’t miss cheese when I went vegan a few years ago. It was not the deal-breaker for me. However, I do enjoy vegan cheese if it’s offered or on sale. I like Daiya a lot and make my own cashew cheese. I want to try Miyoko’s Creamery cheese. I’ve heard it’s fabulous!

Leave a Comment